In this article we will address the history of why Andorra is not a tax haven: its process of more than 10 years of international economic and legal opening, its modernization and its determined commitment to attract innovation and foreign capital. And it is that although the youtubers move to the country for their low taxes compared to Spain, the Principality is no longer, unlike a few years ago.
Andorra as a tax haven
To understand why Andorra stopped being a tax haven, you have to know a little of you history. The truth is that this country has been feudal or quasi-feudal until practically nothing, and it was based on traditional laws. However, since the latter part of the 20th century, the Principality has been a fairly prominent country in the world despite its status. For example, in the hippie years of the 1960s, in the midst of the Cold War's military and atomic escalation, the United States praised the long tradition of peace, neutrality and demilitarization of the Pyrenean Principality.
The reason was that Andorra spent a year 4 dollars and 90 cents in weapons and, unlike other major countries, it was a safe country. At that time, the country was indeed a tax haven for Spain and France, and it survived from the financial services that it provided as a refuge for capital coming from abroad and from the smuggling of products without direct taxes applied, especially tobacco.
In this decade, in addition, Andorrans experienced a huge increase in your quality of life thanks to trade (favored by its status as a tax haven and smuggling) and tourism began to develop with the first sports facilities for skiing. The need for labor produced by economic success caused a strong immigration from Spain and, to a lesser extent, from Portugal, which would end up outnumbering the national population.
However, it was not until 1993 when Andorra was a democratic and non-feudal regime. In that year, the first written Constitution in its history was approved in a referendum, which created a modern parliamentary government system and on July 28 of that same year, Andorra became a full member of the United Nations Organization.
Despite Andorra's non-stop economic and demographic expansion (of non-national population) since the 1960s, Andorra has always maintained a special restriction on nationality as well as a latent discrimination against non-nationals. These limitations on the basic rights of Andorran residents were criticized for their discriminatory nature and anachronism and constituted the greatest obstacle to the internal stability and social welfare of the country.
Residents were only denied the right to vote and political participation. They were also restricted from participating in the unions, and they could not be presidents of a private company or have more than 33% of the share capital of a company. It is a fact that it could afford it, since the status of a tax haven with a flourishing economy and commercial and smuggling traffic and the recent tourism established was more than enough to attract foreign residents.
Therefore, yes, at that time until the beginning of the 21st century, Andorra was nourished by the refuge of opaque and illicit capital and the smuggling of products such as tobacco, and was ignored by practically the entire international community.
A little tap
This paradise located between France and Spain, however, was not perfect. With a concentrated economy, protectionist and highly influenced by its neighboring countries, Andorra suffered the world economic crisis and the Spanish in particular. They had their bubble and subsequent puncture in the real estate market and all economic sectors were hit more or less harshly, although their three most important horses, the financial sector, commerce and tourism endured.
The fact is that they had understood for years in the Principality that had take action and that being an opaque tax haven was perhaps counterproductive, and they embarked on a reform path to usher in a new and more prosperous era. Andorra would never be the same again and its changes continue to develop even today, advancing in the economic diversification and opening its doors to this increasingly globalized world.
Andorra ceases to be a tax haven
The first measure adopted in this regard was the tax information exchange agreement with Spain, signed in 2010. The agreement allowed them at the end of the year exit the list of tax havens in Spain. That year the taxes on income from economic activities (IAE), on income from non-tax residents (IRNR) and on companies (IS) are also approved. Andorra learned for the first time what the taxes really.
The following year Andorra closed an agreement by which since 2011 it is off the OECD blacklist of tax havens and since 2012 on the gray list, partly forced by the circumstances of the world crisis and signed the Monetary Agreement with the European Union to establish the euro as official currency in the country of the Pyrenees and thus approach positions.
In 2012, a single advance was made in this regard, but perhaps the most powerful of all, especially in terms of economic openness. Andorra enacts one new Foreign Investment law to attract foreign investment and diversify its economy. This measure greatly liberalizes the investment non-nationals in the country, greatly limiting the historical discrimination they had suffered.
With this reform, the limitation to companies with more than 50% of foreign capital is lifted, thus ending the typically Andorran figure of “prestanoms”, which is how the figureheads with whom the restriction on foreign investment had been avoided for years were known. Also, it liberalized the exercise of liberal professionals for non-nationals. In this way many people begin to moving to Andorra through one of the Andorran residence permits.
Following the time line, during 2013 and 2014 Andorra took a series of decisions towards its homologation with Europe. In January 2013, the first "VAT" of Andorra, the IGI (general indirect tax). Then in October it agrees to establish tax measures equivalent to those of the EU, and in November it signs a mutual assistance agreement on tax matters with the OECD. Finally, in April 2014, the Personal Income Tax was approved.
The case of the BPA (Private Bank Andorra)
Everything was following its course for 2015, and the Principality signed in January with Spain a non-double taxation agreement. The problem was when in March of that year, the Anti-fraud department (Fine) of the United States Treasury accused the Private Bank of Andorra (BPA), one of the largest banks in the country and with 100% Andorran capital, of money laundering, which tarnished the image of Andorra that sought not to be considered a tax haven.
The threat of the United States to cut all financial relations with the bank made that neither correspondents nor other entities wanted to relate to it anymore. When, within a few hours, his operations collapsed, he was intervened. As the Andorran government leaders said, BPA died that day, and almost took the entire Andorran financial sector with it, which at that time represented 24% of GDP (now it is less).
Behind this, the Andorran Government transferred the case to the Prosecutors Office and the Andorran Finance Institute (INAF), which closed the BPA, and proceeded to transfer its healthy assets to another bank. This bank, All Band, entered the auction and was acquired by a US fund. In addition, Andorra anticipated the adoption of European entity resolution regulations and commissioned an audit of PwC to separate suspicious clients.
We will not go into more detail on this case, but the point is that although the resolutions were forceful and Fine ended withdrawing his accusation, andorra image ended up severely damaged, and even more after the rumors and prejudices of smuggling. In the words of the Foreign Minister of yesteryear: “In Andorra, we are not going to deceive ourselves, we have an image problem. Either they don't know us, or unfortunately they know us from the past. ”
An image problem
This, of course, had its good part and its bad part. Because how to solve an image, opacity and corruption problem after applying the appropriate measures? With a policy of transparency, surveillance and integration in the European environment. Let's say Andorra was struggling to remove that annoying tax haven label but it was not going well.
Furthermore, it was not only a financing problem as Andorran banks lost credibility, because it reduced the results of opening up to foreign investment as the banks became very strict, slow and cautious when it came to opening bank accounts to companies.
And being a country that has balanced public finances, debt at reasonable levels, which deserves recognition from rating agencies after years of crisis, and after the effort in tax matters with double taxation agreements with France or Spain they were still, socially stained. This brutally accelerated a reform process that the country needed to fit into today world.
End of banking secrecy in Andorra
So, in the legislature they got down to work. In November of that same year, Andorra signed with the EU the agreement for the automatic exchange of tax information it had previously drawn up with its neighboring countries, and in 2016 the non-double taxation agreement with Spain entered into force.
After closing the BPA case with the sale of its assets to a US fund, Andorra completely eliminated bank secrecy in January 2017. Since then, the five banking entities have been obliged to collect the information of all their clients, who must share it with Spain and the rest of the countries with which there are agreements.
Subsequently, an agreement with the EU began to be negotiated to access its market and internationalize, the procedures for accession to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) began, and the fiscal crime was typified for the first time. Also, a new money laundering and terrorist financing law and a new insurance law were enacted, among other tax and financial regulations.
These measures generated their results in 2018, when after reforms in the Corporate Tax law to modify and eliminate some bonuses, the ministers of economy and finance of the European Union (Eco fin) agreed that Andorra definitively leave the gray list of tax havens, considering that the country has a cooperative jurisdiction in tax matters.
In that same year, it was written a labor and union reform in depth, lengthening maternity leave, reducing severance pay and regulating the right to strike.
Conclusion and results
The results of the reforms are being quite positive, which drives new measures in this direction. A constantly growing population and GDP, with more than 9,000 established and growing companies, a modern banking system and solvent public accounts add to the very good health system, very attractive fiscal framework o draft environmental reforms to make the Principality a new country.
Andorra has been trying to modernize and adapt to this connected, changing and globalized world for more than a decade. With its pluses and minuses, has managed to carry out a series of reforms that have completely changed the country. They are right now in that strange adaptation phase, having a hard time getting used to exposing themselves to the world after so long in protectionist obscurantism and isolationism.
If they achieve their objective, and it is a fact that they are gradually achieving it, they can become a society fully open to foreigners (with freedom of movement of capital, people and goods), internationally approved, respected and valued, and with a tax and legal framework of the most attractive in the world. An explosive combination for success and prosperity.
The country is currently developing its policies in the call Plan Horizon 23 that we detail here, which includes, for example, the construction of the Grifols immunology center or a massive digitization process albeit unhelpful and wasteful. Also very notable is the launch of the La Seu d'Urgell airport to attract more tourists.
At Abast we believe that now is a splendid time to bet or invest in Andorra, that is why we are here, firm. Now it is your turn to make that decision. If you decide affirmatively, we will be happy to help you in all aspects regarding your establishment in the country. You can contact us and tell us about your case by clicking here. You will receive detailed information on what we can offer you, customizing it to your situation.